To be approved list

From The world of Yarel

This article is basically my to-do list of things to read and either approve or disapprove. You may add things within your own section as you wish - I will go through them from time to time, read them and give my verdict. Once I have approved a rule it will be listed on the approved rules page. Rules that I have failed and will not allow in my game appear on the failed rules page.

Contents 1 Please read this first 1.1 Things I need to know 1.2 Knock-on effects 2 Rules to approve, by player 2.1 Matt 2.2 Graham 2.3 Geoff 2.4 Dan 2.5 Neil 2.6 Caroline 2.7 Trevor 2.8 Derek

[edit] Please read this first

Players - you can add anything you want here - feats, classes, prestige classes, skills, equipment, whatever.

Please list things within your section in priority order - that is, the order in which you plan to take those things (not much sense listing something you can't have until level 15 to be approved before something you will want at level 4). When I visit each person's list I will start at the top and work down. I also aim to give everyone fair coverage of my time, IE: I plan to approve everyone's #2 items before I start work on people's #3 items etc.

Also - it might be obvious but I thought I would say it here: If I approve something for one player/character here, than I have approved it for all players and characters. This also means that NPCs and monsters can use it.

[edit] Things I need to know

If you are adding things to this list, then this is the minimum information that I need in order to make an approval decision:

1. The name of the thing that you want approved and what it is (feat, equipment, class etc)
2. Which book I can find it in (A page number would be great)
3. If the rules have any knock-on effects that are outside of the writeup I will read (see below).

[edit] Knock-on effects

Item three (above) is very important: For example, if you ask me for the Mighty blow of omgbbq feat from page 32 of The Ultimate Munchkin's Handbook (let's say I approve it). If on page 50 of the same book there is a rule that says people with the Mighty blow of omgbbq feat get an extra +10 damage against ogres then unless you told me in advance about that rule, before I approve it then you don't get that +10 damage against ogres.

In other words, if you want me to read a small section of a book that I have not read before in order to approve a rule - I won't read the whole book, I will just read the section that you point me to. If there are knock-on effects outside of that small section, then I haven't approved those knock-on effects unless you told me about them in advance.

[edit] Rules to approve, by player

[edit] Matt

[edit] Graham

1. Whirling blade (spell complete arcanee page 129)
2. Meta Magic School focus (feat complete mage page 45)
3. Everybodies favourite killing spell... WRAITHSTRIKE complete adventurer page 158)
4. Sonice Weapon (spell complete adventurer page 157)
5. Burning blade (spell spell compendium page 41)
6. Battle casting (Feat races of the wilds page 148)
7. Minor shape change (feat complete mage page 45)
8. Bite of the werewolf (spell spell compendium page 29)
9. Abjurant champion (prestige class complete mage page 51)
10. Heroics (spell spell, compendium page 113)
11. Spider skin skin (spell, spell compendium page 202)
12. Dragon skin (spell, spell compendium page 73)
13. Draconic might (spell, spell compendium page 72)
14. Night stalker transformation (spell, spell compendium page 148)

[edit] Geoff

[edit] Dan

[edit] Neil

[edit] Caroline

[edit] Trevor

[edit] Derek

• I have approved the duom with some modified/clarified rules. See the note I left on the talk page about where things are placed once I remove them from this list. In the future, after approving/failing things I will just delete them here and you can find them on the approved/failed page. You can remove this note once you have read it.